Movies Shows MoodMatch Explore Services New Pick for Me Games

MoodMatch Explore New Services

CriticCrunch

Movies Shows About How It Works Terms of Service Privacy Policy Contact

This product uses the TMDB API but is not endorsed or certified by TMDB. Streaming availability data provided by Movie of the Night.

You Might Be the Killer (2019) · CriticCrunch

You Might Be the Killer backdrop

You Might Be the Killer

Movie2019·92 min

You Might Be the Killer

Directed by Brett Simmons

Horror Comedy Mystery

A horror comedy film directed by Brett Simmons.

◈ CrunchScore

Top 55%

of all movies · weighted by audience size & source agreement

★ TMDB Audience Rating

5.8/10

191 ratings

About You Might Be the Killer

Counselors are being killed off at summer camp, and Sam is stuck in the middle of it. Instead of contacting the cops, he calls his friend and slasher-film expert Chuck to discuss his options.

Pacing: Brisk (6 of 9)
Tone: Neutral (5 of 9)
Intensity: Moderate (4 of 9)
Complexity: Approachable (4 of 9)
Humor: Funny (6 of 9)
Scale: Intimate (1 of 9)
Spirit: Light (9 of 9)
Texture: Playful, Unsettling
Story Tags: survival of spirit, fate destiny, supernatural, action combat, wilderness, small town, close friendship, anti hero, everyman, mystery disappearance, unreliable narrator, cat and mouse, serial killer, slasher, monster creature

You might like You Might Be the Killer if you enjoyed…

Tucker and Dale vs. Evil

Tucker and Dale vs. Evil

2010

Comedy · Horror

This Is the End

This Is the End

2013

Action · Comedy

Leprechaun Returns

Leprechaun Returns

2018

Horror · Comedy

Glass Onion: A Knives Out Mystery

Glass Onion: A Knives Out Mystery

2022

Comedy · Crime

Flypaper

Flypaper

2011

Mystery · Comedy

More Like You Might Be the Killer

Matched by mood, pacing, and story

Leprechaun Returns

Leprechaun Returns

2018

briskneutralmoderate

Scary Movie

2000

briskneutralheightened

Paramount+

Out of the Dark

Out of the Dark

1995

briskneutralmoderate

The Jester 2

2025

cat and mousesurvival of spiritfate destiny

The Mean One

2022

briskmoderateprominent

The Little Shop of Horrors

The Little Shop of Horrors

1960

briskmoderateprominent

Prime Video

Thesis

1996

mystery disappearancecat and mouseserial killer

Bride of Chucky

Bride of Chucky

1998

briskmoderateprominent

Terrifier 2

2022

cat and mousesurvival of spiritfate destiny

Peacock

Stitches

2012

briskmoderateprominent

The Leopard Man

The Leopard Man

1943

cat and mousefate destinyserial killer

Jason Lives - Friday the 13th Part VI

Jason Lives - Friday the 13th Part VI

1986

briskmoderateprominent

Paramount+

Where to Watch You Might Be the Killer

You Might Be the Killer is not currently available on any tracked service.

Details

Director: Brett Simmons
Language: English

Cast

Fran Kranz, Alyson Hannigan, Brittany S. Hall

⬡Explore cast & crew→

How You Might Be the Killer Ranks

All movies

Top 55%

2010s movies

Top 47%

Horror movies

Top 54%

2010s Horror movies

Top 41%

★Brett Simmons films#1 of 4

Brett Simmons's highest-rated film in our catalog.

the vibe

You Might Be the Killer Vibe

What it feels like

briskneutralmoderateapproachablefunnyintimatelight

playful

unsettling

What it's about

mystery disappearanceunreliable narratorcat & mousesurvival of spiritfate destinyanti-heroeverymanclose friendshipsupernaturalaction combatserial killerslashermonster creaturewildernesssmall town

pacing

brisk 6/9brisk 6/9

tone

neutral 5/9neutral 5/9

intensity

moderate 4/9moderate 4/9

complexity

approachable 4/9clear 4/9

humor

funny 6/9funny 6/9

scale

intimate 1/9intimate 1/9

spirit

light 9/9light 9/9

texture

playfulplayful